Identity: Lost & Found
February 8, 2026
Epiphany 5
Pastor Horton
Have you ever looked around in the lost and found, and happened to find something that belongs to you? If so, there is a certain sense of joy in what was lost now being found. Was this introduction inspired (perhaps) by our lost and found now outside the church in the entryway, and a longing for you to look over and take your things home? Yes. But the joy in discovering what was lost remains. This happened in a more remarkable way to a college professor. Years earlier, she had lost a book and gave up her search. Years later, she bought a used copy online, and would you believe it? The very book she purchased was her book once lost. The inside cover had her name in her handwriting with the date she placed there all those years ago! She had to share her joyful story with others!
As human beings we understand this in a more profound way. We too like to find our place. We don’t want to feel lost. Be it in the family, in the community, at school or in our career, we are more settled when we find our footing and often tend to project our identity and define it based upon who we are, what we do, and how we think. Identity is by definition, “the fact of who or what a person or thing is.” And we kind of like to have those known facts about ourselves solidified and secure. I hold this job and get paid that salary. I have these political beliefs and have that outlook. I live in this community and have that hobby. I am known for this sense of style, I have achieved that accomplishment. Switch up those reliable facts about ourselves, and we go through a phase of “identity crisis.” If you have moved away from home, or are retired after years in the workforce, or have graduated from school and are looking to the future, or come home from a war, or have faced personal tragedy, you know how your projected identity can be challenged. You know how you can feel a bit lost in life. Maybe you know what that is like right now – maybe you have been wrestling this feeling of being lost for most of your life.
God gives to us today something more sure and certain than our vantage point from wherever we are at in life. He gives us a God-given identity in Jesus that raises our eyes of faith no matter what we are going through. He speaks reassurance to our troubled hearts, and the inspired writer Peter had an audience filled with suffering believers, who certainly had their own doubts soon to follow. We, like those early Christians, often wonder about God’s guiding hand in our life. Is he even there? And does he even care? Most reassuringly “yes” we are told today in our reading. For your God has revealed your salvation accomplished through Jesus – and here is what your identity now looks like in Christ – for we are found thanks to the mercy of God.
Listen, dear child of God, reborn through Jesus, and given a living faith to believe, to verses 9-10, “But you are a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, the people who are God’s own possession, so that you may proclaim the praises of him who called you out of darkness into his marvelous light. At one time you were not a people, but now you are the people of God. At one time you were not shown mercy, but now you have been shown mercy.” That verse 10 simply shouts both law and gospel! The law is blunt. More than identity confusion or crisis, we were utterly lost. “One time you were not a people!” This was our identity upon entrance into this world: “sinful” at our conception. David is clear on that in Psalm 51. Walk it back further and we find Adam and Eve, desiring to be like God, doubting his steadfast love poured out in abundance, and wondering if they needed to take matters into their own hands to improve upon what they were….as if they could improve upon their own identity. “Hang on to what you said there, God, we see a chance to better ourselves.” And they were wrong. Dead wrong. Sin and death went spilling through the ages. That was our status by birth: lost. What’s more is this phrase, “At one time you were not shown mercy.” A tough talk for any and every one of us who try, as we so often do, that we can by our own thinking and choosing do something to earn God’s favor, maybe just a smile from the Almighty, be it ever so small. A tough talk for the religious peoples…in the words leading up to our verses, many in Israel would stumble at salvation through Jesus alone. And the temptation still exists for us. You and I know the extreme excuses we tell ourselves to try and quell our guilty consciences. And yet our handmade badges of honor and good deeds earn us nothing before the Lord. Apart from his acting to save, we have nothing. He should turn his back to us, and close the door on our eternity forever. We should be lost to hell for good. But that is not what he has done.
Rather, he looks upon us and shows us “mercy,” he undertook the great plan to save you and to “bring you into his marvelous light.” He saved you and claimed you as his very own that you know with confidence that “you are the people of God.” This has been accomplished through Jesus. This is Jesus’ identity revealed. Our God has FOUND you lost ones. Why would God do such great things for us? Entirely because of mercy! Out of mercy his plan was created from before time and he knew and chose you to be found as his own. Out of mercy Jesus lived, died, and rose to remove your curse of our sin and throw off death so that you might have a future in heaven. Out of mercy God has revealed to you the saving message of the gospel and helps you live with your new identity, not lost but found and secure in Jesus.
And what does your identity look like to God? It’s shockingly different from the viewpoint of the surrounding world. How would the world view those persecuted and mistreated early believers? How does the world often ID you and me? As a people who are embarrassingly optimistic? Seeking self-help? Foolish individuals with misplaced hope? Lowly? Downtrodden? Listen instead to how God describes you: “But (rather) you are a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, the people who are God’s own possession.” Chosen to be part of the royal priesthood! Look around the church and find royalty all around you – those whom God has highly valued, sacrificed for, those whom we can respect and serve. For they, and you, now have a place next to Jesus upon his royal throne in heaven. You are part of God’s dearly loved family, and cared for by the Almighty himself. You are also a royal priest, having full access to the Father through Jesus in prayer. Your life includes selfless, sacrificial acts of service to God. You may not be an ordained pastor, but carry the gospel of salvation in Jesus with you wherever God directs you. You have your identity there in the cross of Jesus – and in his mercy. As people cleansed by the blood of Jesus, we have been gifted a kingdom ID badge. And our identification is shared with our brothers and sisters in the faith alongside us. View each other as part of the holy nation, unified by faith in Jesus, richly sharing the gifts and abilities God the Holy Spirit has given to his church. Moved by God’s great mercy, that impacts the way we think and speak about our brothers and sisters around us. Now we will want to encourage, support, and build each other up with prayer and thanksgiving – operating within the bonds of Jesus’ love.
And we are also given purpose, “so that you may proclaim the praises of him” who accomplished such great acts of salvation for us! Moved by that mercy God has given you, many more still are in need of the saving message of the cross. It is with this perspective, Peter writes an inspired plea, “Dear friends, I urge you, as aliens and temporary residents in the world, to abstain from the desires of the sinful flesh, which war against your soul. Live an honorable life among the Gentiles so that even though they slander you as evildoers, when they observe your noble deeds, they may glorify God on the day he visits us.” Dear friends keep yourselves always in this message of Christ Jesus. And God will help you keep your eyes and hearts upon your Savior. The big picture is important! Eternity is coming. Don’t launch yourself back into the box of “Lost souls.” Watch out for those sins which blemish your ID in Jesus. Be careful not to dishonor his name, and worse, be careful you do not become that stumbling block to another soul in need of knowing about the gift of eternal life through Christ.
Once lost, we have been found and saved by our God. What an incredible comfort to find our identity not in how we think about ourselves, or in the current facts we know to be true about ourselves, but rather we find comfort in finding our ID in Jesus. We are his and he is ours. What great perspective we now have as a people belonging to God! What great acts of service with which he now includes us for the salvation of souls! Thank you Lord Jesus, for your great acts of mercy to us! Thank you for finding us, equipping us with your gospel, and helping us show mercy. May your kingdom continue to be revealed as you seek and save the lost that many more may be found in you! Amen.
